🇺🇸 United StatesThe Yogurt Shop Murders
The Story
On December 6, 1991, four girls aged 13 to 17 were killed during a robbery and fire at an Austin yogurt shop. Two men were convicted in 1999; both convictions were overturned in 2009 when DNA on evidence did not match them. The case remains open with no current suspects in custody.
Timeline
Four girls are killed during a fire at the yogurt shop in Austin.
Robert Springsteen and Michael Scott are convicted.
Convictions are overturned after DNA on evidence excludes both men.
Known Evidence
How well-documented and physically verified the case evidence is.
- Crime-scene evidence of binding, gagging, and arson at the shop.
- 1999 convictions of Robert Springsteen and Michael Scott overturned in 2009.
- Male DNA on evidence that does not match convicted men or known suspects.
- Confessions obtained under extended interrogation later ruled unreliable.
Unresolved
What We Still Don't Know
- The source of unmatched DNA found on victim evidence.
- Whether the overturned convictions targeted innocent men.
- How many perpetrators participated in the robbery and murders.
Hypotheses
Theories
Ranked by plausibility — highest first.
Unknown Third-Party Offender
The true killer's DNA remains in evidence; convicted men were wrongfully implicated.
Original Convictions Were Correct
The right men were convicted but DNA contamination or secondary transfer exonerated them technically.
Nearby on the map